Satantango, starts in some mouldering Hungarian hamlet, the home of the workers of a collective long since closed and stripped of anything of worth, and like the inhabitants of the hamlet forgotten by the outside world. In fact the only growth market appears to be rot and spiders, very little happens here. Within the first few pages we realise that the rot has spread to all and sundry, there is not a single character of worth, all are, to varying degrees, corrupt, paranoid and full of loathing whether of self or of their neighbours. We also learn that they are waiting for Irimias, who may or may not be Satan, not that this matters as these individuals are so deep into the morass of all that’s bad about humanity, that Satan would be worried about contamination. The villagers wait at the inn for Irimias, who has been seen on the road heading their way with his sidekick Petrina, which is strange because Irimias, is supposed to be dead. Irimias has the ability to charm and mesmerise all to his way, even those who are deeply suspicious of him, still follow his bidding even parting with the collective’s small pot of money. This leads to a series of events that breaks what little bonds they once held and violence erupts, although this is brief as all are so ensnared by Irimias machination, that they can see little else.
Although this may be alluded to within the book Krasznahorkai, is not one for spelling things out. Irimias may be the devil/ trickster or just some cheap con man. With the action (?) confined pretty much to the hamlet, this book come across as really claustrophobic, everything cycles through like the seasons, but unlike the seasons nothing is resolved there is no growth everything appears thwarted, even stunted. The dance just goes on with no joy or release – just an increasing heaviness, everything simmers and yet the kettle doesn't boil, the pressure cooker doesn't release its pressure. There is no end.
This book has also been described as an indictment of Hungarian Collective farming in the dying days of communism and a reaction to the reality of the capitalist dream on a communist utopia. It has also been described as a book on the nature of storytelling. None of this is spelled out in the book, as stated above, very little happens on the page, like the stage direction “Offstage action”, most of what happens here, happens within your head and continues to do so long past the turning of the final page.
This post is a series of reactions to what is basically a very simple story and yet I cannot write a cohesive review of it. The obvious place to start would be that it is divided into 12 chapters, most consisting of a single paragraph, or that the book is split into two with the chapters in the first part going from one to six and in the second part from six to one, also the last chapter is named The circle closes, which is apt. The book is set in the twentieth century, although it’s shading would lends itself to some medieval setting, or anything apocalyptic. Referring back to my kettle analogy and taking it to it’s conclusion, the kettle boils dry leaving only the husks of what was once human, the threshings of humanity.
All that I've written are bullet points, headlining some points yet neglecting others, I guess like storytelling itself, in that you choose a certain path whilst omitting others, and even whilst on that path you do not see, or choose not to see everything - defining yourself and your tale by what you put forward. Satantango, circles on itself like some mythical serpent and within that circle the characters dance their own isolated geometries like marionettes in some brutal puppet play, whilst the story eats it’s own tail.
As previously stated, this is a book that happens more in the mind than on the page, this makes it all the more baffling and all the more interesting, what I didn’t state is that I have read three books since Satantango, and it still haunts me - still has me trying to comprehend what this paradoxically simple tale is all about.
"The imagination never stops working but we're not one jot nearer the truth," – Irimias
This book’s translator was George Szirties, whose skill in translating this novel into a language that I could read gets my undying thanks. Although my understanding of Hungarian is somewhere below nil and thus I’m not able to judge how accurate the translation is, I can form an opinion of how it reads in my own language and it reads beautifully.
George Szirties (1948-) is a poet and translator who settled in England after his family fled the Hungarian Uprising of 1956. He currently teaches creative writing at the University of East Anglia in Norwich, England and is trained as a painter. His poetry has won many awards, including the Faber Memorial Prize (1980), the T.S. Eliot Prize (2005) and the Forward Poetry Prize (2009).
New Directions (László Krasznahorkai)
www.László Krasznahorkai
15 comments:
Sounds like my kind of book :)
This'll be the last of the IFFP reads for me - if and when my copy gets here :(
I'm so envious of the availability you have for these books contending for the IFFP! Please, someone tell Amercan libraries and bookstores that not everyone wants to read of romance and vampires...
Smashing review, Gary, insofar as it has only whet my appetite to try Krasznohorkai soon (another title of his has been on my TBR stack for ages) and "Satantango": I recommend Bela Tarr's film adaptation of the book if you have a spare eight hours! P.S. to Bellezza: This book is super easy to find where I live (and is also available online); let me know if you ever need help finding a book because college town bookstores are the best!
This sounds like a wonderfully intense read. I do wish my state library system and Perth bookstores would be a bit more adventurous and make available books that challenge us and make us think, instead of piling their shelves with more of the same egregious piffle. If only I could deal with eBooks, eh?
Thanks, Richard, but there's another problem: I just discovered this week that A Death in The Family by Knausgaard is titled My Struggle in the U.S. Excuse me? How does that help?! :)
Sounds like a fascinating book. I have often thought about the archetype of the Trickster myself so I found your commentary very insightful.
As to your comments about the nature of your post. I do not really believe in "Reviews". I think that as you alluded to, it is so much more useful to talks about the points of a work that interest one at the moment. Sometimes that necessitates ignoring major aspects of a work.
Hi Tony, this is one for those who are happy to be contemplating a book long after they've finished it. So you should enjoy.
Hello Bellezza, it's not been that easy for all the titles some my library had, some they're getting, some I've gone begging from publishers & some I've purchased this one as an Ebook from Google play. It's a bit like the Swan analogy all calm & grace above the water & flapping about like a lunatic beneath. Best of luck with your hunt. :-)
Thanks Richard, I've already tracked down my next Krasznahorkai & hopefully it will arrive soon & I'll find the space to read it.
Ps which other Krasznahorkai, have you got?
Hi Violet, our library of late has been affected by the current crisis & has had extensive cutbacks which I guess has a knock on to what they have in Stock for example reduced numbers of copies shared over a wider area :-(
Hi Brian, yes I've found in the past that the term "review" sticks in the throat with its implication of a professional critique, which is far from my interest in posting on any facet of literature. I tend to find a point of interest, a way in to the book and work from there.Sometimes it works & others I end up with a collection of ideas with no cohesive structure, but as long as I can get across that I liked/loved this book I'm happy
Great post. Intrigued with the structure and style of the book. I see similarities between the Irimias character and someone in The Melancholy of Resistance. And the image of the perpetually boiling kettle is truly apocalyptic.
Thanks Rise, read several posts that state of similarities between this and Melancholy, making me wanting to read that. The idea of the kettle/pressure cooker was that intense build up of pressure in a confined space with no release.
Gary, your exchange with Rise reminds me I forgot to answer your question: The Melancholy of Resistance. What's the new Krasznahorkai that you picked up by chance?
Richard i went for War and war, purely chosen because I had not heard of it and the blurb intrigued me, I also noticed there's a new one out in may called Seibo There Below from New Directions (I think) which has a Japanese connection so I maybe raiding the piggy bank again.
Many thanks for the mention I m, pleased this was my first book by him as it was his debut ,I love its style and the4 fact it is so challenging ,all the best stu
And now I come to your wonderful review four (five?) years after you have written it. I love how you point out that the people are in a morass or all that's bad about humanity, and that Irimias may (or may not) be Satan. I responded to your comments on my post before rereading yours, and I am somewhat assuaged that I am not far off the mark. Or, we are off the mark together. Ultimately, he writes of the woes of society, yet I wish he would have been a bit clearer. Are they the fault of the people or the leaders, the industry or the government or simply fate? And, I would like to know what he would suggest about getting out of the muck and mire we are finding ourselves in. (I have my own opiniIns, but I did not write this book, and therefore am interested and his.) Perhaps it is enough that he is able to depict calamity as well as he does, and offer us an opportunity to come to our own conclusions.
It's that very fact that he doesn't spell it out but leaves it to you so interpretation is a collaborative process between the writer & reader a bit like Japanese art poetry where using the bare minimum creates an intimacy where the meaning is not billboarded at you but becomes an ever changing process depending on when & who you are when you engage with his writing I think you'll enjoy Seibo There Below here's a newspaper link to a review of it
https://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/may/20/seiobo-there-below-by-laszlo-krasznahorkai-review-winner-man-booker-international-prize
Post a Comment