Friday, November 26, 2010

Literary Bookhop.

Classic/Modern/Contemporary?

What makes a contemporary novel a classic?
Discuss a book which you think fits the category of ‘modern classics’ and explain why. This is the question posed for this week by the ladies of the Blue Bookcase &  if you ignore the inherent contradiction between the terms classic & contemporary & go to what I believe is the very heart of this idea, then my definition would be.

If a classic is a book that has transcended its place and time, whether that is through its ability to be understood as a definition of what it is to be human, or as a key to understanding that dilemma. Then a contemporary classic by definition would be, a novel that although written now would fulfil this criteria. So regardless of its subject matter it could be judged by this definition, by this  I mean, whether we are discussing the spaceships from Mars 2156 or the cultural nuances of  Augustine Rome 395-476, you may or may not understand all the cultural or technological  references, but you can understand the humanity of the characters

.Following this lead my next problem is to break down my list of possible books, for example any one who just glances sideways at this blog, will expect me to have a Roberto Bolano book in this list, but which one 2666 has got to be a contender, if not already possessor of the prize, yet what about The savage detectives, Distant Star, Nazi Lit etc. In the end I decided to pick what is probably my favourite

Last Evenings on Earth.

AlthoughThisbookyoumustread_thumb18 this probably shouldn’t count, as it’s actually compiled from  2 previous collections (Llamadas Telefonicas & Putas Asesinas) of Bolano's, it doesn't feel bolted together & despite  this, the book is addictive. By the time you've started the third story, you will belong to these characters, it will matter what happens to them. The French poet who shone in the resistance only to fadeout as a teacher in some  remote village, the exiled writer who goes home to recover his sons body then  languishes & dies, or just following Ann Moore's life from the age of 20 - 40. It will matter, fold the corner on the page, put the book down, leave the room & it will be there, just behind your eyes, in between your thought processes, it will be the beat that paces your journeys, it's shadow will dog your footsteps & your sleeping self, will continue to turn the pages.

As I’ve already started to take liberties, with my selection process, for my next choice I’ve decided to take “Contemporary” literally, as in “Belonging to the present time, Current, Very modern, Up to date” &  the book in question was in contention for this years Man Booker Literary prize & although it lost out in the end, I’m making it my Contemporary Classic

C by Tom McCarthy

c-m_1694820f_thumb54

Tom McCarthy plots a large story using a microscope, to zero in at certain aspects before pulling back for a wider perspective and this has a wide perspective, covering everything from the life cycle of silkworms, early telecommunications, through the first world war fighter planes and Egyptology. Using my definition of a classic, this book ticks all the boxes,the characters absolutely scream their humanity from the cries of a freshly swaddled babe to that final rattle alone with your thoughts, or your maker.

For my final choice I’m choosing another war based novel, I don’t know much about this author, having so far only managed two of his works so my choice is based on personal like & base ignorance, he may have written better books than my choice, but that's part of my journey as a reader. As a  reader in the west, I’ve seen and read lots of stories about the war from a western perspective, this book and author introduced me to a different view, in the process fulfilling perfectly the role of good literature, that being to open your eyes to other worlds & through that increase your understanding.

The Sea & Poison by Shusaku Endo.

Shusako_Endo_thumb[2]The book starts as a prologue, with the visit to a  “ shabbily constructed house, more like a shed than a Dr’s surgery” by an unnamed man seeking a Doctor for a routine injection. He meets Dr Suguro, whose faultless technique, but cold distant attitude, piques his curiosity. A while later, whilst at a  family wedding, he meets another doctor who is a fellow guest, they get chatting & he finds out that the other doctor knew Suguro & through his tale we learn about Dr Suguro’s past.

11 comments:

Letter4no1 said...

I never thought about how well War novels would stand up to the test of time, but I think your right. It's a very universal occurrence that most will always be able to at least understand.

Lovely List. Love your blog!

Sarah @ Loving Books

Ben said...

Of all three I know only Shusaku Endo and I wholeheartedly agree with this nomination. Have you read "A Life Of Jesus"? "Obaka San" the english title roughly translates as "Mr.Idiot". It's a disturbing read.

Thanks for the suggestions. My TBR pile just gets thicker.

petekarnas said...

I haven't read any of these but all three look wonderful. Will have to add them to the list...

parrish lantern said...

Hello Letter4no1(Sarah?)
I think the heightened emotions, tensions etc. can probably in a good writers hand, act like a microscope focusing on all that's good & bad about humanity.
Thanks for your compliment.
Parrish

Hi Ben, not read this book but has been suggested before, so is on my Tbr & now has jumped a few notches.
Thanks for the heads up.
Parrish

Hi Pete, all are good books, The Bolano is just a fantastic collection of short stories & if you've not read any Bolano,a good start. The
McCarthy is a really good read & if you like Pynchon, there's a fair chance you'll like this And the Endo is just one of those books where you have to know what happens, It's the 2nd book of his I've read (1st, Stained glass elegies) & won't be the last.
Thanks,
Parrish.

Amy said...

C sure has been getting a lot of buzz. The Sea and Poison--never heard of it, but sounds like it's right up my alley.

Caroline said...

I watch a lot of war movies (also have a blog on war movies http//allaboutwarmovies.com) as I grew up with a veteran father (being French he fought in Algeria) but I can't really read books on the topic. It seems as if my imagination makes things look worse than what I see when watching a movie. I am not saying I don't cringe sometimes but never like when reading a novel. Odd. The only movie that shocked me was Derek Jarman's War Requiem. Horrifying original footage. I'm sorry. I'm slightly off topic.
I defintely need to read the Bolano and will explore the Endo.

parrish lantern said...

@Amy: Hi Amy, I obviously believe C merits the attention it receives & if you'd like to endo a try I'd recommend either this one, or Stained Glass Elegies (reviewed).
Thanks,Parrish

parrish lantern said...

@Caroline: Hi Carol, I'm not a great film buff,although my favourite film set during a war is Apocalypse now & also have no personal experience of the effects of war on an individual or their family, so cannot comment. Yet through reading the thoughts others have, I can probably get as close as I would like. If you'd like to try a Shusaku Endo, not totally set around the war, give Stained Glass Elegies a go (reviewed) thanks for your comment
Parrish

Caroline said...

Thanks for the recommendation. He will be added to my wish list.

Bellezza said...

Oh for goodness sake, I thought for sure I'd left a comment here! Suffice it to say that I take your recommendation of Endo's book quite seriously, having been throroughly engrossed with both Wonderful Fool and Silence. I still need to read more Bolano, though.

parrish lantern said...

@Bellezza: Hi, Bellezza, it was reading your review of Silence ( june ) that made me originally add the you book to my TBR, The way you compared it to your own faith expressed in America.
Thanks for your comment
Parrish
Ps, you sound a bit stressed(lol)